Home
About Us
Search Library
Library Index
Whats New
Links
Training
Statement of Faith
About Us
Admin Login
Believersweb Header

Warning #4 to the Church

Written by: Ryle, J.C.    Posted on: 04/09/2003

Category: Sermons

Source: CCN

                                                                Preface

For more than a century, J. C. Ryle was the leader of the evangelical party in the Church of England.  His policy was to encourage the conservative men to remain in the church rather than to abandon ship and leave the liberals to pursue their program unhindered.

J. C. Ryle is best known for his plain and lively writings on practical and spiritual themes.  His great aim in all his ministry, was to encourage strong and serious Christian living.  But Ryle was not naive in his understanding of how this should be done.  He recognized that, as a pastor of the flock of God, he had a responsibility to guard Christ's sheep and to warn them whenever he saw approaching dangers.  His penetrating comments are as wise and relevant today as they were when he first wrote them.  His sermons and other writings have been consistently recognized, and their usefulness and impact have continued to the present day, even in the outdated English of the author's own day. 

Why then should expositions already so successful and of such stature and proven usefulness require adaptation, revision, rewrite or even editing? The answer is obvious.  To increase its usefulness to today's reader, the language in which it was originally written needs updating.

Though his sermons have served other generations well, just as they came from the pen of the author in the nineteenth century, they still could be lost to present and future generations, simply because, to them, the language is neither readily nor fully understandable.

My goal, however, has not been to reduce the original writing to the vernacular of our day.  It is designed primarily for you who desire to read and study comfortably and at ease in the language of our time.  Only obviously archaic terminology and passages obscured by expressions not totally familiar in our day have been revised.  However, neither Ryle's meaning nor intent have been tampered with.                                                   Tony Capoccia

All Scripture references are taken from the HOLY BIBLE: NEW INTERNATIONAL VERSION (C) 1978 by the New York Bible Society, used by permission of Zondervan Bible Publishers. 

                        Warning #4 to the Church

                        Pharisees and Sadducees                                   by                               J. C. Ryle                               (1816-1900)

                    "Be careful," Jesus said to them.                   "Be on your guard against the yeast                     of the Pharisees and Sadducees."                                            (Matthew 16:6)

Every word spoken by the Lord Jesus is full of deep instruction for Christians.  It is the voice of the Chief Shepherd.  It is the Great Head of the Church speaking to all its members--King of kings speaking to His subjects--the Master of the house speaking to His servants--the Captain of our salvation speaking to His soldiers.  Above all, it is the voice of Him who said, "I did not speak of my own accord, but the Father who sent me commanded me what to say and how to say it" (John 12:49.)  The heart of every believer in the Lord Jesus ought to burn within him when he hears his Master's words: he ought to say, "Listen! My lover!" (Song of Solomon 2:8).

And every word spoken by the Lord Jesus is of the greatest value.  Precious as gold are all His words of doctrine and teaching; precious are all His parables and prophecies; precious are all His words of comfort and of consolation; precious, the not least of which, are all His words of caution and of warning.  We are not merely to hear Him when He says, "Come to me, all you who are weary and burdened;" we are to also hear Him when He says, "Be careful and be on your guard."

I am going to direct attention to one of the most solemn and emphatic warnings which the Lord Jesus ever delivered: "Be on your guard against the yeast of the Pharisees and Sadducees."  On this text I wish to erect a beacon for all who desire to be saved, and to preserve some souls, if possible, from making their lives a shipwreck.  The times call loudly for such beacons: the spiritual shipwrecks of the last twenty-five years have been deplorably numerous.  The watchmen of the Church ought to speak out plainly now, or forever hold their peace.

I. First of all, I ask my readers to observe "who they were to whom the warning of the text was addressed."

Our Lord Jesus Christ was not speaking to men who were worldly, ungodly, and unsanctified, but to His own disciples, companions, and friends.  He addressed men who, with the exception of the apostate Judas Iscariot, were right-hearted in the sight of God.  He spoke to the twelve Apostles, the first founders of the Church of Christ, and the first ministers of the Word of salvation.  And yet even to them He addressed the solemn caution of our text: "Be careful and be on your guard."

There is something very remarkable in this fact.  We might have thought that these Apostles needed little warning of this kind.  Had they not given up all for Christ's sake? They had.  Had they not endured hardship for Christ's sake? They had.  Had they not believed Jesus, followed Jesus, loved Jesus, when almost all the world was unbelieving?  All these things are true; and yet to them the caution was addressed: "Be careful and be on your guard."  We might have imagined that at any rate the disciples had little to fear from the "yeast of the Pharisees and of the Sadducees."  They were poor and unlearned men, most of them fishermen or tax collectors; they had no desire to follow the teachings of the Pharisees and the Sadducees; they were more likely to be prejudiced against them than to feel any drawing towards them.  All this is perfectly true; yet even to them there comes the solemn warning: "Be careful and be on your guard."

There is useful counsel here for all who profess to love the Lord Jesus Christ in sincerity.  It tells us loudly that the most eminent servants of Christ are not beyond the need of warnings, and ought to be always on their guard.  It shows us plainly that the holiest of believers ought to walk humbly with his God, and to watch and pray so that he won't fall into temptation, and be overtaken with sin.  None is so holy, that he can't fall--not ultimately, not hopelessly, but to his own discomfort, to the scandal of the Church, and to the triumph of the world: none is so strong that he cannot for a time be overcome.  Chosen as believers are by God the Father, justified as they are by the blood and righteousness of Jesus Christ, sanctified as they are by the Holy Spirit--believers are still only men: they are still in the body, and still in the world.  They are ever near temptation: they are ever liable to misjudge, both in doctrine and in practice.  Their hearts, though renewed, are very feeble; their understanding, though enlightened, is still very dim.  They ought to live like those who dwell in an enemy's land, and every day to put on the armor of God.  The devil is very busy: he never slumbers or sleeps.  Let us remember the falls of Noah, and Abraham, and Lot, and Moses, and David, and Peter; and remembering them, be humble, and be careful so that we don't fall.

I may be allowed to say that none need warnings so much as the ministers of Christ's Gospel.  Our office and our ordination are no security against errors and mistakes.  It is true, that the greatest heresies have crept into the Church of Christ by means of ordained men.  Ordination  does not confers any immunity from error and false doctrine.  Our very familiarity with the Gospel often creates in us a hardened state of mind.  We are apt to read the Scriptures, and preach the Word, and conduct public worship, and carry on the service of God, in a dry, hard, formal, callous spirit.  Our very familiarity with sacred things, unless we watch our hearts, is likely to lead us astray.  "Nowhere," says an old writer, "is a man's soul in more danger than in a minister's study."  The history of the Church of Christ contains many dismal proofs that the most distinguished ministers may for a time fall away.  Who has not heard of Cranmer recanting and going back from those opinions he had defended so stoutly, though, by God's mercy, raised again to witness a glorious confession at last?  Who has not heard of Jewell signing documents that he most thoroughly disapproved, and of which signature he afterwards bitterly repented?  Who does not know that many others might be named, who at one time or another, have been overtaken by faults, have fallen into errors, and been led astray?  And who does not know the mournful fact that many of them never came back to the truth, but died in hardness of heart, and held their errors to the end?

These things ought to make us humble and cautious.  They tell us to distrust our own hearts and to pray to be kept from falling.  In these days, when we are especially called upon to cleave firmly to the doctrines of the Protestant Reformation, let us be careful that our zeal for Protestantism does not puff us up, and make us proud.  Let us never say in our self-conceit, "I shall never fall into the errors Roman Catholicism or any New Theology: those views will never suit me."  Let us remember that many have begun well and run well for a season, and yet afterwards turned aside out of the right way.  Let us be careful that we are spiritual men as well as Protestants, and real friends of Christ as well as enemies of antichrist.  Let us pray that we may be kept from error, and never forget that the twelve Apostles themselves were the men to whom the Great Head of the Church addressed these words: "Be careful and be on your guard."

II. I propose, in the second place, to explain "what were those dangers against which our Lord warned the Apostles."  "Be careful," He says, "Be on your guard against the yeast of the Pharisees and of the Sadducees."

The danger of which He warns them is false doctrine.  He says nothing about the sword of persecution, or the love of money, or the love of pleasure.  All these things no doubt were perils and snares to which the souls of the Apostles were exposed; but against these things our Lord raises no warning voice here.  His warning is confined to one single point: "The yeast of the Pharisees and of the Sadducees."  We are not left to conjecture what our Lord meant by that word "yeast."  The Holy Spirit, a few verses after the very text on which I am now dwelling, tells us plainly that by yeast was meant the "doctrine" of the Pharisees and of the Sadducees.

Let us try to understand what we mean when we speak of the "doctrine of the Pharisees and of the Sadducees."

(a) The doctrine of the Pharisees may be summed up in three words: they were formalists, tradition-worshippers, and self-righteous.  They attached such weight to the traditions of men that they practically regarded them of more importance than the inspired writings of the Old Testament.  They valued themselves on excessive strictness in their attention to all the ceremonial requirements of the Mosaic law.  They thought much of being descended from Abraham, and said in their hearts, "We have Abraham for our father."  They fancied themselves because they had Abraham for their father that they were not in danger of hell like other men, and that their descent from him was a kind of title to heaven.  They attached great value to washings and ceremonial purifyings of the body, and believed that the very touching of the dead body of a fly or gnat would defile them.  They made a great deal about the outward parts of religion, and such things that could be seen by men.  They made broad their phylacteries, and enlarged the fringes of their garments.  They prided themselves on paying great honor to dead saints, and garnishing the graves of the righteous.  They were very zealous to make converts.  They prided themselves in having power, rank, and preeminence, and of being called by men, "Teacher, Teacher."  These things, and many things like these, the Pharisees did.  Every well-informed Christian can find these things in the Gospels of Matthew and Mark (See Matthew 15 and 23; Mark 7).

Remember, all this time, they did not formally deny any part of the Old Testament Scripture.  But they brought in, over and above it, so much of human invention, that they virtually put Scripture aside, and buried it under their own traditions.  This is the sort of religion, of which our Lord says to the Apostles, "Be careful and be on your guard."

(b) The doctrine of the Sadducees, on the other hand, may be summed up in three words: free-thinking, skepticism, and rationalism.  Their creed was far less popular than that of the Pharisees, and, therefore, we find them mentioned less often in the New Testament Scriptures.  So far as we can judge from the New Testament, they appear to have held the doctrine of degrees of inspiration; at all times they attached greater value to the Pentateuch [first five Books of the Old Testament] above all the other parts of the Old Testament, if indeed they did not altogether ignore the latter. 

They believed that there was no resurrection, no angels, and no spirits, and tried to laugh men out ot their belief in these things, by bringing forward difficult questions.  We have an instance of their mode of argument in the case which they propounded to our Lord of the woman who had had seven husbands, when they asked, "At the resurrection, whose wife will she be of the seven?"  And in this way they probably hoped, by rendering religion absurd, and its chief doctrines ridiculous, to make men altogether give up the faith they had received from the Scriptures.

Remember, all this time, we cannot say that the Sadducees were downright infidels: this they were not.  We may not say they denied revelation altogether: this they did not do.  They observed the law of Moses.  Many of them were found among the priests in the times described in the Acts of the Apostles.  Caiaphas who condemned our Lord was a Sadducee.  But the practical effect of their teaching was to shake men's faith in any revelation, and to throw a cloud of doubt over men's minds, which was only one degree better than infidelity.  And of all such kind of doctrine: free thinking, skepticism, rationalism, our Lord says, "Be careful and be on your guard."

Now the question arises, Why did our Lord Jesus Christ deliver this warning?  He knew, no doubt, that within forty years the schools of the Pharisees and the Sadducees would be completely overthrown.  He that knew all things from the beginning, knew perfectly well that in forty years Jerusalem, with its magnificent temple, would be destroyed, and the Jews scattered over the face of the earth.  Why then do we find Him giving this warning about "the yeast of the Pharisees and of the Sadducees")

I believe that our Lord delivered this solemn warning for the perpetual benefit of that Church which He came to earth to establish.  He spoke with a prophetic knowledge.  He knew well the diseases to which human nature is always liable.  He foresaw that the two great plagues of His Church on earth would always be the doctrine of the Pharisees and the doctrine of the Sadducees.  He knew that these would like two large rocks, between which His truth would be perpetually crushed and bruised until He came the second time.  He knew that there always would be Pharisees in spirit, and Sadducees in spirit, among professing Christians.  He knew that their succession would never fail, and their generation never become extinct, and that though the names of Pharisees and Sadducees were no more, yet their principles would always exist.  He knew that during the time that the Church existed, until His return, there would always be some that would add to the Word, and some that would subtract from it, some that would tone it down, by adding to it other things, and some that would bleed it to death, by subtracting from its principal truths.  And this is the reason why we find Him delivering this solemn warning: "Be careful and be on your guard against the yeast of the Pharisees and of the Sadducees."

And now comes the question, Did not our Lord Jesus Christ have good reason to give this warning?  I appeal to all who know anything of Church history--was there indeed not a cause?  I appeal to all who remember what took place soon after the apostles were dead.  Do we not read that in the primitive Church of Christ, there rose up two distinct parties; one ever inclined to err, like the Arians, in holding less than the truth, the other ever inclined to err, like the relic worshipers and saint worshipers [of the Roman Catholic Church], in holding more than the truth as it is in Jesus?  Do we not see the same thing coming out in later times, in the form of Roman Catholicism?  These are ancient things.  In a short paper like this it is impossible for me to enter more fully into them.  They are things well known to all who are familiar with records of past days.  There always have been these two great parties, the party representing the principles of the Pharisee, and the party representing the principles of the Sadducee.  Therefore our Lord had good cause to say of these two great principles, "Be careful and be on your guard."

But, I desire to bring the subject even nearer at the present moment.  I ask my readers to consider whether warnings like this are not especially needed in our own times.  We have, undoubtedly, much to be thankful for in England.  We have made great advances in arts and sciences in the last three centuries, and have much of the form and show of morality and religion.  But, I ask anybody who can see beyond his own door, or his own living room, whether we do not live in the midst of dangers from false doctrine?

We have among us, on the one side, a group of men who, wittingly or unwittingly, are paving the way to the Church of Rome [Catholicism]--a school that professes to draw its principles from primitive tradition, the writings of the Fathers, and the voice of the Church--a teaching that talks and writes so much about the Church, the ministry, and the Sacraments, that it makes them like Aaron's rod which swallows up everything else in Christianity, a teaching that attaches vast importance to the outward form and ceremony of religion, to gestures, postures, bowings, crosses, holy water, seats of honor for the clergy, altar cloths, incense, statues, banners, processions, floral decorations, and many other like things, about which not a word is to be found in the Holy Scriptures as having any place in Christian worship.  I refer, of course, to the school of Churchmen called Ritualists.  When we examine the proceedings of that school, there can be but one conclusion concerning them.  I believe whatever be the meaning and intention of its teachers, however devoted, zealous, and self-denying, many of them are, those whom has fallen the cloak of the Pharisees.

We have, on the other hand, a school of men who, wittingly or unwittingly, appear to pave the way to Socinianism, a school which holds strange views about the absolute inspiration of Holy Scripture, and stranger views about the doctrine of sacrifice, and the Atonement of our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ, strange views about the eternity of punishment, and God's love to man, a school strong in negatives, but very weak in positives, skillful in raising doubts, but impotent in removing them, clever in unsettling and unscrewing men's faith, but powerless to offer any firm rest for man.  And, whether the leaders of this school mean it or not, I believe that on them has fallen the cloak of the Sadducees.

These things sound harsh.  It saves a vast deal of trouble to shut our eyes, and say, "I see no danger," and because it is not seen, therefore not to believe it.  It is easy to cover our ears and say, "I hear nothing," and because we hear nothing, therefore to feel no alarm.  But we know well who they are that rejoice over the state of things we have to deplore in some quarters of our own Church.  We know what the Roman Catholic thinks: we know what the Socinian thinks.  The Roman Catholic rejoices over the rise of the Catholicism: the Socinian rejoices over the rise of men who teach such views as those set forth in modern days about the atonement and inspiration.  They would not rejoice as they do if they did not see their work being done, and their cause being helped forward.  The danger, I believe, is far greater than we are apt to suppose.  The books that are read in many quarters are most mischievous, and the tone of thought on religious subjects, among many classes, and especially among the higher ranks, is deeply unsatisfactory.  The plague is abroad.  If we love life, we ought to search our own hearts, and try our own faith, and make sure that we stand on the right foundation.  Above all, we ought to take heed that we ourselves do not drink the poison of false doctrine, and go back from our first love.

I feel deeply the painfulness of speaking out on these subjects.  I know well that speaking plain about false doctrine is very unpopular, and that the speaker must be content to find himself being thought of as very uncharitable, very troublesome, and very narrow-minded.  Thousands of people can never distinguish differences in religion.  To the bulk of men a clergyman is a clergyman, and a sermon is a sermon, and as to any difference between one minister and another, or one doctrine and another, they are utterly unable to understand it.  I cannot expect such people to approve of any warning against false doctrine.  I must make up my mind to meet with their disapproval, and must bear it as I best can.

But I will ask any honest-minded, unprejudiced Bible reader to turn to the New Testament and see what he will find there.  He will find many plain warnings against false doctrine:

"Watch out for false prophets" (Matthew 7:15).

"See to it that no one takes you captive through hollow and deceptive philosophy" (Colossians 2:8).

"Do not be carried away by all kinds of strange teachings" (Hebrews 13:9).

"Do not believe every spirit, but test the spirits to see whether they are from God" (1 John 4:1).

He will find a large part of several inspired epistles taken up with elaborate explanations of true doctrine and warnings against false teaching.  I ask whether it is possible for a minister who takes the Bible for his rule of faith to avoid giving warnings against doctrinal error?

Finally, I ask any one to mark what is going on in England at this very day.  I ask whether it is not true that hundreds have left the Established Church and joined the Church of Rome [Roman Catholic Church] within the last thirty years?  I ask whether it is not true that hundreds remain within our boundaries, who in heart are little better than Romanists?  I ask again whether it is not true that scores of young men, both at Oxford and Cambridge, are spoiled and ruined by the withering influence of skepticism, and have lost all positive principles in religion?  Sneers at religious newspapers, loud declarations of dislike to "denominations," high-sounding, vague phrases about "deep thinking, broad views, new light, free handling of Scripture, and the barren weakness of certain schools of theology," make up the whole Christianity of many of the rising generation.  And yet, in the face of these notorious facts, men cry out, "Hold your peace about false doctrine.  Let false doctrine alone!" I cannot hold my peace.  Faith in the Word of God, love to the souls of men, the vows I took when I was ordained, alike constrain me to bear witness against the errors of the day.  And I believe that the saying of our Lord is eminently a truth for the times: "Be on your guard against the yeast of the Pharisees and of the Sadducees."

III. The third thing to which I wish to call attention is "the peculiar name by which our Lord Jesus Christ speaks of the doctrines of the Pharisees and of the Sadducees."

The words which our Lord used were always the wisest and the best that could be used.  He might have said, "Be careful and be on your guard against the doctrine, or of the teaching, or of the opinions of the Pharisees and of the Sadducees."  But He does not say so: He uses a word of a peculiar nature--He says, "Be careful and be on your guard against the 'yeasts' of the Pharisees and of the Sadducees."

Now we all know what is the true meaning of the word "yeast."  The yeast is added to the lump of dough in making a loaf of bread.  This yeast bears but a small proportion to the lump into which it is mixed; just so, our Lord would have us know, the first beginning of false doctrine is but small compared to the body of Christianity.  It works quietly and silently; just so, our Lord would have us know, false doctrine works secretly in the heart in which it is once planted.  It insensibly changes the character of the whole mass with which it is mingled; just so, our Lord would have us know, the doctrines of the Pharisees and Sadducees turn everything upside down, when once admitted into a Church or into a man's heart.  Let us mark these points: they throw light on many things that we see in the present day.  It is of vast importance to receive the lessons of wisdom that this word "yeast" contains in itself.

False doctrine does not meet men face to face, and proclaim that it is false.  It does not blow a trumpet before it, and endeavor openly to turn us away from the truth as it is in Jesus.  It does not come before men in broad day, and summon them to surrender.  It approaches us secretly, quietly, insidiously, plausibly, and in such a way as to disarm man's suspicion, and throw him off his guard.  It is the wolf in sheep's clothing, and Satan in the garb of an angel of light, who have always proved the most dangerous foes of the Church of Christ.

I believe the most powerful champion of the Pharisees is not the man who bids you openly and honestly come out and join the Church of Rome: it is the man who says that he agrees on all points with you in "doctrine."  He would not take anything away from those evangelical views that you hold; would not have you make any changes at all; all he asks you to do is to "add" a little more to your belief, in order to make your Christianity perfect.  "Believe me," he says,

      We do not want you to give up anything.  We only want you to       hold a few more clear views about the Church and the       sacraments.  We want you to add to your present opinions a       little more about the office of the ministry, and a little       more about episcopal authority, and a little more about the       Prayer-book, and a little more about the necessity of order       and of discipline.  We only want you to add "a little more"       of these things to your system of religion, and you will be       quite right. 

But when men speak to you in this way, then is the time to remember what our Lord said, and to "Be careful and be on your guard."  This is the, yeast of the Pharisees, against which we are to stand upon our guard.

Why do I say this? I say it because there is no security against the doctrine of the Pharisees, unless we resist its principles in their beginnings:

1. Beginning with a "little more about the Church"--You may one day place the Church in the place of Christ. 

2. Beginning with a "little more about the ministry"--You may one day regard the minister as "the mediator between God and man."

3. Beginning with a "little more about the sacraments"--You may one day altogether give up the doctrine of justification by faith without the deeds of the law.

4. Beginning with a "little more reverence for the Prayer-book"--You may one day place it above the Holy Word of God Himself.

5. Beginning with a "little more honor to Bishops"--You may at last refuse salvation to every one who does not belong to an Episcopal Church.

I only tell an old story: I only mark out roads that have been trodden by hundreds of members of the Church of England in the last few years.  They began by faultfinding at the Reformers, and have ended by swallowing the decrees of the Council of Trent [Roman Catholic Doctrinal Council].  They began by crying about the way things were, and have ended by formally joining the Church of Rome.  I believe that when we hear men asking us to "add a little more" to our good old plain Evangelical views, we should stand upon our guard.  We should remember our Lord's caution: "Be on your guard against the yeast of the Pharisees."

I consider the most dangerous champion of the Sadducee school is not the man who tells you openly that he wants you to lay aside any part of the truth, and to become a free-thinker and a skeptic.  It is the man who begins with quietly insinuating doubts as to the position that we ought to take up about religion, doubts whether

Doc viewed 7616 times.

Related Content


This articles keywords/phrases are:

false doctrine

The articles in the list below have 1 or more of the same keywords or phrases as the article you are viewing. If you wish to hone in on a single keyword, click on that keyword and you will see a list of articles that match just that keyword.



FIFTEEN REASONS WHY I CAN'T BE A JEHOVAH'S WITNESS   in Cults / Sects / Non Christian Religions and Topics

Development and hosting
for non-profits and more